SOS. Operation: The Feels

I'm 16 and at the beginning of this last school year I liked someone who is 18 (let's call him Joseph).  We actually became pretty close friends fast and I told him that I liked him after three months of knowing each other (in December).  He's had a girlfriend (also 16) for over half a year now (they started dating in early August), but he always complained about her... so this is why I thought it was okay to reveal my feelings for him.  Well, he declined feeling the same but we are still close friends today.  In March, I got a boyfriend who I had kinda liked in the past (were both 16).  Obviously, I have feelings for the guy (let's call him Tyrese) now otherwise we wouldn't be dating.  Also, Tyrese knows about Joseph.  I feel for Joseph on such an emotional level, but Tyrese and I just click.  I guess I don't really have a question to ask you guys, besides what do you think of my situation.