Should I go on a second date?

I went on a first date this weekend and he took me to a very fancy restaurant. Convo was great, he was hot and intelligent. Then  when we got our food, he made them return it because the mashed potatoes were touching the meat. He said to the waitress "I specifically asked for the meat and potatoes to be separate and not touching, can you please make me a new plate". It was a $60 plate too! I didn't return his texts today. Am I overreacting? I keep thinking, if he's like this with food, what else?? 

Vote below to see results!