Girl names

I for the life of me can't pick a name for a girl! I've gone through hundreds of names & none of them seem to stick. I like names that are classic but not overly used. Right now we have Natalie & Samantha. I'm to the point where I want to say F it & let him pick whatever name he wants because their just all so blah to me. Can anyone suggest something that we might not of considered? (PS my SO is super traditional)