CM confusion- two types?

Kaitlin • Wife to SB. Mommy to PB and LJ.
This is my first month TTC. My glow said I began being fertile Thursday (6/11) however when I enter my Period dates on other ovulation calculators online they said my fertile dates are 5/15-5/19. Anyways. So I checked my CM. When I originally pulled my finger out, it was white, thick, kind of tacky/stickyish. However right after when I wiped to clean up I noticed slippery clear mucus and when I touched it it could stretch about 1/4 of an inch or so. I'm not really sure which to record? We aren't using ovulation tests since this is our first time but I'm just trying to figure it all out. Thank you!