Which would you choose?

My wedding is vintage theme, and everything is DIY. We arent having a caterer, so i have to get all the plates. This me u is brunch finfer foods, so its not a heavy meal. I can source real vintage, mismatched plates like the first picture for cheap at thrift stores on their sale days, getting them for anywhere from $.50 to a couple bucks each. Then we would have to worry about a bucket to put them in and carrying them back to the car and i feel awful disposing of them but wouldnt want to wash them all either. Or i can get all matching vintage paper plates for about $2-$3 each like the second picture which obviously have more benefits but will be more expensive. Which would you go with and why?