Pick b/w two boys????!

There are two boys- S and E.

I met S last year at work (I’m a camp counselor) and we hit it off super hard. We had fun the entire summer, and he was dating a girl named Angie who he loved so much. (Broke up 3 months ago)

I met E in school two years ago.

SO E likes me so much. Like we went to prom together and he’s liked me for months. So I was hanging at his house the other day and he kissed me and it turned out into a makeout session. I still don’t know if I like this kid though, Idk. So this evening, I went out to dinner with S because he just got back from China. So we went out and came back to my place. We just talked and talked, played a small game, talked and wrestled and talked some more. Eventually after I told a super personal story, we started cuddling and he put on some music and it was sooo nice. It is his birthday today and we just hugged a lot and he kissed me on the cheek before we went upstairs (For him to leave). He’s cute and sweet and we can just talk about anything. So now what do I do about E because he is so nice and likes me a lot but I think I like S more. Please let me know what you would do!!?