Just be honest

Amber • Married for 10 years and expecting our second child.

I really just want honest opinions. I promise it won’t hurt my feelings. My husband and I decided on the name Madelyn Rose and every time I tell someone the name we picked I get less than thrilled responses. No ones flat out said they don’t care for it but I don’t really get the “Oh that’s cute” or “I like/love that”. Is it not a good name? Too over done?