Toddlers and soothers... when did you stop?

Lori • Wife, mom x3, 2MC, 🤰#4 & #5 ♥️🇨🇦🐄

We have a 2 yr old who is attached to his soother. He always has been. We’ve finally gotten it down to just bedtime and it’s been maybe 1.5-2 months of that. But we also have a 8 month old who has a soother, 2 yr old is always trying to take. I say no that it Ts so he gives it back. So I just cold turkey take his away or is there another way that works?