Confusion

So I am in a bit of a dilemma. It’s kind of annoying and a long story so I get it if you don’t wanna read the whole thing. SO. I explained this to my friend and she called it a “love octagon” 😂 yeah I know but it’s because I kind of like 3 different guys (not really a crush I just find them objectively attractive, and like if they were to ask me out I would probably say yes) me and my ex gf are just waiting to get back together because we decided to wait until we are older to try again with our relationship, and 4people like me. Yeah. So things are a bit complicated. I have told them gently but surely that I don’t like any of them but some keep trying anyways. I have all of my interest’s numbers because we are in the same math class and I made the group chat and people just added who they had ( that was my evil plan the whole time 😌😏) I’m a bit confused but there is one that I have made sort of a deeper connection with than the others but he is totally against my religion, but I’m scared to tell him because he won’t like me anymore but at the same time, if he doesn’t accept me for who I am then 💁‍♀️ idk it’s a lot and I’m not sure which to focus on because I want to date someone now but there’s at least one thing that makes me not want to date them with each person so 🤷‍♀️