Need help with naming one twin!

Hey, everyone!

My husband and I have named one twin, but we are at a loss for the second! 🙈 We have scoured family trees, the internet, and even our friends’ names!! What old fashioned/classic girl name suggestions do you have? We thought we had picked out a middle name, but since we can’t find a first name we like to go with it, we may scrap it.

Looking for any and all help!

Thanks in advance! 💕

The twin that we have named is Eliza, forgot to mention that!