Nursing pillow recommendation

Emily

I have a brand new boppy (still in package) that was on my registry. My aunt bought it and shipped it to me. My other aunt bought a different nursing pillow and shipped it to me with a cover.

So now I have 2 different pillows and cover for them.

Should I keep both? Should I return one? Does anyone have a preference between the traditional boppy and the pillow pictured.