Who's diaper bag is more convenient & durable?

Freshly Picked's Birch Classic Diaper Bag:

https://freshlypicked.com/products/birch-diaper-bag

Fawn Design's The Original Diaper Bag:

https://fawndesign.com/products/the-original-diaper-bag-lilac

My daughter's almost a year old and I need a bigger diaper bag now that she needs more stuff. I originally really wanted the Skip Hop Greenwich but the majority of the reviews said the zippers dont hold up. Clearly, I want something classy and elegant but if I'm gonna splurge I really need it to be versatile, convenient, and last for years. Any mommas been using either of these bags for a while?