Relationship advice

I used to date this guy i met on tinder (lets call him toast) and it went really great. We had a little spark and he understood me. Long story short we were together for 2 months and broke up because i apparently made a big deal out of his roommate being a girl and him not telling me. I got back on tinder and met this guy and he is great(we’ll call him orange). We have a lot of similarities and we talk a lot and we’ve connected mentally, a little more than the other guy. But he was more like a rebound but now i actually like him. A couple days ago i hung out with my ex (toast) and I stayed with him at a hotel for 2 days and he kept saying he had missed me. Then when he dropped me off at work he told me he loves me...also he’s been reassuring me a lot lately. And he wants me to go on a trip with him next month. Buuut orange and i talked and he said he likes me a lot but he doesn’t want a label yet. Basically saying he doesn’t want a relationship atm.

WHO DO I CHOOSE😭