BF likes me to wear makeup.

Alex • 25, ABD&OB/GYN RDMS
He asked me "babe why don't you try to look hot anymore? How come as more time goes on in the relationship you stopped wearing makeup everyday and dressing up and smelling good. I want you to make your eyes pop like they used to."
I gotta alittle hurt from this and took it in a way that I'm ugly without makeup and stuff... He said I took it the wrong way and that he's asking I do it more often not everyday. We been together for 3 years.
How would you ladies take it if you SO said this to you? Just looking for some security and reassurance that I may just have taken it wrong lol