Help Ladies Need Breast Pump Advice

Al
My insurance provider covers both the Medela PISA starter kit as well as the Spectra S2 kit. I've ready tons of reviews but am still stuck on which to choose. Which one did you prefer and why? Did you use both? I'm not planning on exclusively pumping as I will be home with the baby, but I will be using it so dad and family are able to feed her also.