Which Daycare? Help!

Nicole
I need opinions/advice!! I am in between 2 centers for infant care. They are within minutes of each other so distance isn't a factor. 
One is $60 a week part time, open 7am-5:30pm. It is in an older building and the layout is odd (infants are the first room when you enter). We know several people who send their kids there and are happy. 
The other is $95 a week part time, open 6:30-6pm. It's in a newer, nicer building and infant room is secured in the rear. 
We work 12 HR shifts so the extra time being open is nice, but not sure it's worth the extra money? Advice??