I'm super pale!

Megan • We are the universe. Treat it well. ✨🌟🌌🌄⛰
I can never find the right shade of foundation for my skin. Usually I buy ivory/porcelain but some brands make it look so caked on even when I just use a small dab of it. Any cruelty free suggestions? 
I'm also clueless as to what shades to use for eyeshadow. 
I'm more of a dark color person but it's kind of difficult when you're so pale you glow in the dark. 😂😂