We are 100% ready for a baby! Except...

Mo
Hi everyone!
My fiancé and I are totally ready for a baby. Financially, we're golden. Huge savings in the bank and good pay checks each week. We've been together 3 years and are getting married next fall. We're starting to shop for a house this summer and have already been approved for a 240k house (lots to work with yay!) 
As far as schedules go we're both in bed no later than 8:30pm and are up and running at 4am(if not sooner) We both are physically healthy and eat very well. We don't drink besides the occasional drink if we go out for a date on the weekends. We don't smoke. We moved to a new state than where we met because we didn't like the people there and genuinely don't miss parties or concerts. We prefer each other's company and find having a lot of friends and seeing them too often to be tedious (I have a few anxiety issues)
We've traveled and been on trips our whole relationship. 
We talk about babies all the time. He always says "our son." "When we have a baby." And things like that. We already have names picked out and have to try and stop ourselves from buying baby clothes when we're out because they're so cute! The other day we were at target and he always stops to look at kid clothes and jokingly put baby socks in the cart one time and said we should leave them lying around to see if anyone notices (we're mean pranksters) 
We also have walked through the furniture (baby stuff) aisles at target and picked out cribs and baby camera monitors and discussed it AT LENGTH. We even have agreed when we get a house we'll pick a baby room and paint it yellow with a duck theme. He goes out of his way to spend time with children and misses when his cousins were babies. Anytime we're out and about and see a baby he is so interested and wants to know everything I know about them (I've worked with children for our whole relationship and even before) 
All the signs point to him wanting to have a baby and our current lifestyle would truly support one. We wouldn't be giving up very much at all. 
Except...
He says he doesn't want one right now and claims to never think about when he would want one. He thinks we aren't ready. 
Why would he do all of that then!!! 
Edit: I don't care about when we have a baby btw. The baby can be at my wedding or live in our apartment with us. I would love my life either way.