What toy should I use?

So I tried a vibrator called the "butterfly" for the first time last night with my bf. It's supposed to stimulate your clit and g spot at the same time, but to be honest I absolutely hated it and was like "babe your fingers give me a TON more pleasure than this piece of crap" which made him feel good, but we still want to try some new things. So, what toy should we try next? Problems with the vibrator: I didn't feel like it was doing anything for my clit, and I felt like it wasn't long enough. Any suggestions?