Birthday gift for boyfriend??

Elizabeth
Hey there!
So my boyfriends birthday is coming up and I've had a few ideas bouncing around my head as to what to get him. We're both musicians and I wrote a song for him, but he hasn't heard it yet. So I thought about maybe getting it recorded professionally and putting it on a cd or a vinyl for him. But I don't want his gift to be about me. Would that be weird or am I just overthinking it? Thanks! 
-e