Breast pumps through insurance

Ok, so I know this has been asked time and time again... I have just been approved by insurance for a breast pump. I have always heard Medela and Spectra are the ones to chose between. The ones listed are what my insurance covers. They offer the Spectra S2 but I have to pay $30. My question is should I choose one of the free ones or pay to have the Spectra? I havent even heard of the brand Motif.

I had planned to breastfeed my 1st but she never would latch. I pumped for about a month before giving up. I had received a First Years brand pump with her and it was terrible. If I cant BF this baby, I plan to exclusively pump so I need a pump that will last and that will work best. All opinions and experiences are greatly appreciated.