I think I'm in love with 2 people!

I've been dating my boyfriend for 10months and we have always been good to me and things are great I love him with all my heart. He brings me so much happiness, enjoy and love that I haven't felt in years. Before I met my boyfriend I was talking with someone I been knowing for 5+ years he has always been in love with me but I've been had mixed feelings about this person. I feel like a bad person alot of you guys might judge me but is it possible to love 2 people? The old saying there's love and lust but I know what lust feels like and that's not the case here.

Any advice? Plz keep negative comments to yourself.