Would it be weird?

I had an amazing extended first date with an amazing adorable sexy man. We have planned for the second date to be movies at my place (we have already had sex so don't try to warn me that's what's happening). Anyway we do both actually like movies and watching them so I'm thinking of getting some snacks for when we're actually watching the movie. Would it be creepy if I bought the bottled version of the beer he ordered on our first date and a snack he mentioned he really likes?

I don't want to come off as stalker-ish but I often remember these little details about people so would it be cute/thoughtful or weird and creepy?