Stuck In Limbo

Serena • Soon to be first time mom. Trying for our little "Caramel Macchiato" Harris. TTC#1
It's currently CD25 and I'm so lost on this cycle. Mainly because it's been forever since TTC but instead of testing and tempting I just decided to wing it. BD on CD 13&15 had EWCM on CD16 since CD14 I have dull cramps and have gotten more noticeable around CD22 where it was mostly on one side. Tested on CD23 and got a BFN since ovulation I have had thick creamy cm. The only thing that's different is the cramping I'm having never happens only when AF is here. Possibly pregnant?