lost virginity-felt nothing?

So I lost my virginity last week(I'm 17 so legal age) on Monday to my boyfriend who wasn't a virgin previously. His penis is above average at 6"8 and is quite girthy so it hurt a bit to put in but then I felt nothing, and I mean nothing. We had sex again the Wednesday and I again felt nothing but we had to start partway through as I was bleeding. We have done doggy, missionary and me on top and I felt nothing still so I'm scared it won't ever feel good. Fingering however does feel really good so I'm confused as to why this doesn't. We had sex with and without a condom and it made no difference plus I get really wet down there so lubrication wasn't a problem, what's wrong with me?