Losing the big v-card??

I've been dating this guy for over a year now (I'm 16) and although I know that a lot of people say high school relationships don't last, I feel really special with this guy. Considering my last relationship he is the most nicest guy that I have ever met and I'm so glad that he keeps up with my shit lol. I have thought about losing my virginity to him but there is one problem...he's a virgin too. I'm a little scared that maybe it would just be to awkward for me and him too to actually enjoy the moment. Has anyone been in a position like this? How exactly do I overcome this small "fear"?