I had anal sex a year ago for the first time and it was amazing, we didn't even use lube, (I was super wet) he just easily slid inside of me and it felt so amazing. I love the feeling of anal, but ever since that first time I can't have anal anymore. No matter how much lube, how much I relax, I can barely fit a finger in there anymore. I don't know how to make butt take it anymore which sucks cus I really want my current boyfriend to use my ass. Has this happened to anyone else?