Can I be pregnant having sex once?

Stacie
First... Let me start off by saying I'm in a same sex marriage and have decided to carry a baby for us seeing my wife can no longer have children. 
My periods are very regular. I've never been on birth control. I'm a fairly healthy person. I don't take any medications etc. 
I found a donor. My wife and I decided that I would do it naturally because that is the easiest way to achieve pregnancy
I took an ovulation test on what glow said was my second day in fertile window. I took the test because I experienced a little of the clear egg white mucus and cramping on right side. The ovulation test said positive so I did the deed. It was around 11:30pm so almost the 3rd day of fertile window. 
The donor has high sperm count. And two kids of his own.
My question is could I achieve pregnancy only having sex once? It was very uncomfortable for me and I'd like to not do it again. 
What are my chances for success and what should I be looking for??

Glow Resources

Let’s Glow

Glow is here for you on your path to pregnancy

Glow helps you navigate your fertility journey with smart tools, personalized insights, and guidance from medical experts who understand what matters most.

25+ million

Users

4.8 stars

200k+ app ratings

20+

Medical advisors