Help!! In a relationship but interested in someone else

So my boyfriend and I have been dating for almost 3 years. He’s kind and loving, but at the same time he’s very awkward around other people and it’s kinda embarrassing. He’ll say things out of no where that don’t fit social expectations. Don’t get me wrong, I love him. All my friends love him. And my family loves him. We’ve literally only had one fight ever. He’s a great guy and we fit well together, but we don’t have much of a spark anymore.

Now this other guy...we’ve been friends for a year. All my friends and all his friends hang out 3-4 days a week. We have so much fun and to be honest I have more chemistry with him than my boyfriend. Everyone feels it. My friends have said things to me about the sexual tension and he’s even told one of them that he would “put a ring on it” if I were single. He’s more sociable and funny, but he doesn’t get along as well with my friends than my current boyfriend does.

I’ve been thinking about the two guys for 6-7 months going back and forth. I don’t know what to do. If I had to choose who to spend a weekend with I would honestly choose my friend (the other guy) because we have more fun together. They both make me laugh and smile and I care about them so much. What should I do!?