first time having sex and i couldn't feel anything

so i just had sex with this guy I've been talking with for a few weeks. it was my first time and not great. we made out for a really long time, he was hard we're both horny. i was a lil nervous cause i've like only have masturbated before. so i know what my body responds to and i tried to guide him to turn me on but it was not working for me. he was really into it but nothing was feeling good for me?? so we're making out and all of a sudden he like flips me around so I'm on top and he's hard but when I tried thrusting he'd like just slip out. i wasnt even like really lifting my hips that high to thrust. so we switched again so he was on top again and i knew he was inside me and I could see that he was thrusting hard and fast but dang I wasn't feeling anything! he came and I was just like oh welp guess we're done. and idk i kinda was hoping i'd orgasm but it didn't happen. he was like really into it the whole time and satisfied. but i like want to orgasm so anyone have any tips for the next time??