Teacher Struggles, Need a Girl Name

Alright friends, I'm a teacher and if any of you know a teacher, you know we struggle with associating names with kids we have or have had in the past. Needless to say my poor husband and I can't settle on a name. I also feel like every name we pick isn't good enough for this little girl (which im sure sounds ridiculous)! I need ideas, we've picked a couple, but NOTHING is set in stone. We are due with our girl in March but I really would love to have a name picked sooner. Need help on first and middle names. Like I said, I teach, so no super commom names and neither of us are fans of the old lady type names.

List so far:

Kaya, Braylee, Paisley, Athena