As someone who has used both, I say the Dockatot.👍🏾 Our daughter had the Dockatot Deluxe (now used the Grand), the SnuggleMe Organic, Baby Delight Snuggle Nest, and Snuggle Nest Traveler. All of them are good, but the Dockatot was by far our favorite. Now, we did not use these items as co-sleepers because we did not want to start the habit of bedsharing. However, we used them for naps during the day and our daughter loved the Dockatot.