So, I've been dating two great guys for awhile. Who would you pick?

Guy 1 - PROs are funny, handsome, great job that he loves, makes a lot of money, great family. CONs low sexual chemistry, doesn't give me butterflies, we like a lot of different things.

Guy 2 - PROs are great conversations, caring, great sex, great family, handsome, great personality. CONs bad job, no good career prospects.

My heart says guy 2, but guy 1 is amazing too. I always seem to pick the "fixer upper". Should I go with the hot sex and great conversation, or the comfortabilty and great friend?