Ahould I pus for naturshould I push for naturshould I push for natural birth after having a c section 12 years ago

After having an emergency C-section 12 years ago because I got induced and it wasn’t progressing. Now pregnant with baby #2 was hoping I could have tried naturally since its been a long time, even my scar disappeared . At first a doctor wanted to see if I’m a good candidate to give birth naturally but after having a cerclage at 21 weeks the new doctor do not want to hear about having him naturally, he kept pushing for c section just because my first did not progress. I’m conflicted, not sure if I should go back to the first doctor ( they are both working in the same facility) for a second opinion regarding having him naturally or just give in for the c section. Any advice or experience from any of you would help.