Medela Pump In Style OR Spectra S2PLUS???

Sarah • 35yo — TTC child #2. Living with the struggle of long wonky cycles.

I’m torn.... my insurance will cover either the Medela Pump In Style or the Spectra S2 PLUS. I’ve seen these as the highest rated ones that women seem to love, and I keep bouncing back and forth. I’ve seen people say they had the Medela PIS before but liked the spectra S2 better. And others have said the S2 wasn’t as strong of suction.

Recommendations? Opinions?