Breastfeeding in the evening

My LO does great eating in the morning afternoon and middle of the night but for some reason she hates nursing in the evening. I’ll put her on her side like I normally do and she screams and screams. I’ve never been able to get her to latch with football hold so I haven’t tried that. But in the evening she’ll only take a bottle. I end up pumping to keep up my supply but its really making things difficult with her being so fussy and not wanting to nurse from about 6-10:30. Any advice?