Confused about my feelings 🙁

I have known this guy for 2 years, but we were never close before. We met again through an event and started talking since then. It's only been 2 weeks since we properly got close but I'm unsure about my feelings.

He is not my usual "type", so I thought that I only see him as a friend although I really enjoy his company. I don't think I am physically or sexually attracted to him but I am romantically attracted to him.

He told me that he is interested in me and I replied that I'm unsure. The thing is I think about him a lot, I genuinely care about him and I miss him when he's not around. I know he is good for me and we are very compatible but I still have no sexual attraction towards him. What should I do?