Need opinions on names for #2

We are trying to baby #2 and have been discussing names. Husband’s father is named Edward (goes by Ed and Eddie) and we would really like to use his name somehow. This is likely our last baby, and we incorporated my parents and his mom into our first’s name. If we have a boy, it will be easy, we’ll just name him Edward or use that as a middle name. If we have a girl is where I’m struggling.

Husband really likes Edith (nickname Edie) because the nickname sounds similar to Eddie like his dad. I’m not 100% sold on Edith. I don’t know anyone with the name but, to me, it sounds like an older name.

But right now, we’re thinking Edith Eliza (middle name after my grandmother), Edith Laci (middle after my sister), Edith Marie (also after my sister), or Edith Irene (husband just likes the way it sounds together).

Do you guys like the name Edith? Is it too much of an “old” name?

My first and middle names are both very old fashioned and I never liked it growing up, so I think maybe I’m more sensitive to it than I should be.