Siblings want to name baby? Need help

Question

I need help guys. The day after tomorrow I finally get my anatomy scan and I'm pretty sure I'm having another girl. We already have definitely settled on about name just in case.
So here is my Dilemma. VERY early in pregnancy I had decided on Rosalie if it's a girl. I love longer names that can be shortened easily. The problem is that all of my kiddos have fallen in love with them and refer to baby as Rosalie as they all think it's a girl (they're ages age range from 1.5-5 but they have never been wrong, the oldest two are the most strongly opinionated in the subject.
I was going through an old notebook of names I've kept since ai was a teacher and came across Madeleine and fell in love with it again and am now having second thoughts about Rosalie. My husband loves it too.
So I guess my question is would you let your kids have a day in naming? I'd be happy with either name but my husband prefers Madeleine.
My other children's name for reference:
Benjamin
Marceline
Melody
Harrison

Answer

Madeline Rose if it's a girl? I would name him/her whatever you and your husband want and the kids will get over it.

Answer

I find Madeleine to be a little close to Marceline.

Answer

I like Rosalie Madeleine, first and middle!

Answer

Kids adapt more easily then we think. After you find out if it’s a girl for certain, just sit them down and explain to them that you and daddy decided that you think Madeleine is the best choice for the baby. You could even tell them that you’re open to her middle name being Rosalie/Rosie/Rose so that way Rosalie is still incorporated. We’ve changed our baby’s name multiple times and each time 2 out of our 3 kiddos (4.5, 3, and 1.5) preferred something different lol. We finally settled on MY favorite about a month ago and now they’ve all come around and refer to baby by her new name.

Answer

🤷 I mean I would run it through a family vote but if the kids are 1 1/2 -5 years old I wouldn't really worry too much about them wanting to name the baby and there is still a chance its a boy. Honestly don't stress until you're sure what is coming. The names might not matter if its a boy they cant be used.

Answer

Can you do Rosalie Madeline ? Or Madeline rosalie? 
Or can Rosalie just be a nickname?

Answer

I think Madeleine would go very well with her sisters names. 💕

Answer

I don't know if anyone is still following but I decided to post an update anyways :)
The great debate was all for nigh! We are having another boy! We quickly decided after finding out that the name we had picked for a boy didn't feel right anymore. 
We quickly settled on Quentin John and me and the hubs were both happy. It just made sense. It is a french name, it ends in the "in" sound that I like for boys, and this is our fifth baby. Quentin translates to "the fifth".

Answer

Maybe change the spelling? Madelyn vs Madeleine? Then it doesn’t look so close to your other child’s name. Just a thought.

Answer

If you changed the name the kids would adapt rather easy. I named our 3rd Amelia. My 6 year old is sure she named her, our 3rd is just over one.  But my daughter loved the name so much she’s sure she said it and I agreed 😂

Siblings want to name baby? Need help

Let’s Glow

Glow is here for you on your path to pregnancy

25+ million

4.8 stars

20+

Getting Pregnant

Pregnancy

1st Year (Baby & You)

Baby Products