Baby name poll!

My husband and I decided on one of those names (not gonna say which lol) almost 3 years ago shortly after we started dating. Ever since then, whenever we're at a store and see personalized items we always would look for the name and show each other. We've both gotten used to having it as a girl's name when we had baby. Well now we are and after looking at a baby name book, came across the other name.  It's pretty but doesn't have the same special history that the first one did that we picked out a long time ago. What do you think?