First Date Nerves!

Vicky
Hi Ladies (and gents who are floating around on here)!
Last week, after 6 months of unsuccessful dating and meeting terrible guys through Bumble, I signed up for Match.com.
I have been talking to one of the first guys I met via Match a lot over the last few days and we have a lot in common in terms of interests, beliefs, and values. We've been texting daily and had an hour and a half phone conversation earlier this week. He asked me out, and we are going to be meeting at a baseball game this Sunday. (We're both huge baseball fans, and he paid for the tickets. 😍)
I have a good feeling about this guy, but I'm also completely terrified.
(Context: Prior to the bad Bumble dates, I have dealt with a sexually and emotionally abusive partner, and later on had a great partner who broke my heart. It's been 4 years since my last relationship and I know it's time to get back out there.)
I'm terrified that my good feelings will be wrong, and that the date will go horribly. Am I crazy for thinking that? I've just had so many odd and terrible dates over the last few months...
I know he's nervous too, because we've talked about it. He seems really sweet and really kind, but I'm afraid that it's too good to be true.
Does anyone have any words of encouragement or advice for when you're meeting someone new? 😔