Tooth fairy dilemma

So my son lost his first tooth today. Yay!! He's supper excited. But he lost the tooth. He can't find it. He thinks he may have swallowed it but isn't sure when. Smh. He's not upset about it and already wrote the tooth fairy but I have a question for you ladies!!

I may have a tooth from my oldest child in my jewelry box. I'm sort of saving them by accident. I always ment to throw them away but never got around to it.

Would you pretend that one of those teeth is his tooth? 🤔 for the sake of having the full experience for the first time?