Tarte shape tape or NARS soft matte concealer?

So, I have a bunch of acne I want to cover for school. I'm debating between the two. I've heard great things about both. I want to use them on acne and possibly under my eyes, and I want it to look natural, as I'm not going to wear any foundation (oily skin, would come off right away). Which one should I choose? Thanks!

**note, I also put this in the makeup tips group, but I'm posting it here too, in hopes of getting more replies. Sorry about that!