makeup hunting 😂

A while ago I bought Tarte Lip Paint in the color "tbt" and I love the color so much. However, I've run out and I don't want to spend $20 JUST on lipstick again. 😭

This is the color:

This is how it looks on me (old picture but oh well):

I like the color a lot but don't want to spend so much again. Are there any similar/close colors by less pricey brands like NYX or e.l.f. in a matte finish, preferably at Ulta? I'm having a hard time finding one and if you guys know of one please let me know!!