My CM changed and I am confused.

Yesterday evening, I checked my CM and it was light and more creamy than anything else. Then my DH and I fooled around for a while (no BDing), and afterward, my CM had increased and was dead-on EWCM.

My question is this... I understand WHY my CM changed, but since I was still in the early part of my fertile window, should I log that day as a creamy CM day? Or an EWCM day?

I know for sure I am not ovulating yet, as I am also temping and taking OPKs.

And, for the record, we did BD later in the night! Come on, baby #1!!