lining my eyesπŸ‘€πŸ‘€πŸ‘€πŸ‘€

jess β€’ Noah 10/16/15 πŸ’™ Eli 5/9/19

I'm looking for recommendations for a lower lid eye liner that doesnt smear, stays on especially if my eyes get watery.

I end up with a mess when I use a pencil, I'm using the cheap ones I guess.

Also when I line my top lid and curl my lashes i still end up with a gap where the red arrow is (image below). i figure I'm suppose to tight line that area, but pencil gets messy.