Is my birth control pill enough?

Hey guys my boyfriend and I are having our 1 year anniversary soon and I wanted to surprise him by having sex without a condom for the first time. I really want to and I’ve been on the pill for 2 months now. The only issue is that getting pregnant scares me out of my mind. Should we use another method like spermicide along with the pill or should we be fine?

Also should he cum in me? Should I take plan b after? I’m just so nervous please give me some advice, ladies.