TTC First Time Intro

Hi 😁 I’m Fe and I am new to this group. I live in Fl, just got married in September. Looking for a cycle buddy and advice.

Had sex unprotected with the pull out method for 5 years with no pregnancies. Makes me kind of think something is wrong. In 5 years I would think at least one slip up should of happened.

Currently I’m 9 DPO, all tests have been negatives so far. Should I test again 12 DPO or just wait for my missed period? I hope I get pregnant fast 🤞🏾🤞🏾