Which swing should I get? Fisher Price Starlight Revolve or the Graco Everyway Soother?

Samantha

So I've narrowed it down to the Fisher Price Starlight Revolve or the Graco Everyway Soother. Both have positive and negative reviews, but I think one of the two is what I want to go with. Anyone have either? What do you think? The soother seems a bit loud, which is usually a plus with my babies - and the revolve ONLY revolves, no side to side or back and forth only.. so I just can't decide.