UPDATE! I don't know when to give up...
UPDATE: I think I found one, fingers crossed it stays that way. She seems to be taking to the Playtex Orthopro. Ironically these are the same ones my first born( now 13 years old) would take. The downfall is they are discontinued so I have to order off Ebay.

I am on the desperate hunt for a pacifier for my colicky almost 11 week old baby with silent reflux. I have already tried so many. The pacifier rejects include: Avent Soothies, MAM, Tommee Tippee Ultra Light, Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature, Bibs ( both the original round nip and the contour), Nuk Comfy Orthodontic, Itzy Ritzy. When do I just admit defeat and accept that my baby won't take a pacifier? Any suggestions? She has a hard time settling down to go to sleep and fights her tiredness all the time so I was hoping suckling would sooth her. Plus I read it's good for helping with reflux.. She will suck on my pinky or knuckle but no pacifiers. I'm lucky to get a few sucks on one before she tongue thrusts it out or gags on it.
Let’s Glow
Glow is here for you on your path to pregnancy
Glow helps you navigate your fertility journey with smart tools, personalized insights, and guidance from medical experts who understand what matters most.
25+ million
Users
4.8 stars
200k+ app ratings
20+
Medical advisors